Skip to main content

Investing Without a Plan: The Grocery Store Analogy

Why Buying Stocks Hungry for Action Is Like Shopping Hungry for Food

Justin Caron avatar
Written by Justin Caron
Updated this week

When you walk into a grocery store hungry, you buy too much, too fast, and too randomly.
You grab things you want now, not what you actually need. The same happens in the stock market — buying impulsively, following hype, and skipping research.

This course reframes investing through a simple, universal analogy: shopping hungry vs. investing without a plan.
It introduces a simple mental framework — PAP: Plan → Assess → Proceed — a repeatable protocol that keeps your portfolio disciplined, just like a smart grocery list keeps your pantry balanced.


The PAP Protocol

PAP = Plan · Assess · Proceed

Step

Grocery Store Context

Stock Market Context

Goal

Plan

Decide what you need before shopping.

Define goals, watchlist, entry and exit rules.

Prevent impulse.

Assess

Compare brands, labels, and prices.

Evaluate fundamentals, trends, and risk/reward.

Choose quality.

Proceed

Buy what fits your plan and budget.

Execute trades with discipline and structure.

Take action — but only when aligned with plan.

This cycle repeats before every purchase or investment decision.
It builds discipline by converting emotion into process.


Module 1 — The Hungry Shopper vs. The Impulsive Investor

Objective: Identify emotional behavior and link it to poor investing outcomes.

When Hungry:

  • Every aisle looks like opportunity.

  • Your decisions are reactive, not rational.

  • You forget your list and your budget.

When Emotional in Markets:

  • You chase momentum stocks.

  • You buy without knowing why.

  • You confuse activity with progress.

Lesson:
If hunger clouds judgment at the grocery store, greed does the same in markets.
The fix: Apply PAP before every trade — Plan first, Assess carefully, Proceed only if it fits your framework.


Module 2 — Plan: Create Your List Before You Shop

Objective: Design your investment “grocery list.”

At the Store:

  • Meal prep.

  • Set a budget.

  • Make a list.

In the Market:

  • Define your goal: income, growth, or preservation.

  • Set your asset mix (ETFs, stocks, bonds).

  • Create a watchlist with target entry points.

Best Practice:

  • Pre-write your buying criteria (valuation, yield, momentum).

  • Automate recurring contributions instead of spontaneous trades.

  • Remember: “The list is your defense against the aisle.”


Module 3 — Assess: Check the Label Before You Buy

Objective: Train your analytical discipline.

At the Store:

  • Compare prices and ingredients.

  • Check expiration dates and quality.

In the Market:

  • Compare fundamentals (EPS, P/E, ROE).

  • Assess trend and momentum (RSI, moving averages).

  • Evaluate company “shelf life”: debt, cash flow, leadership quality.

Apply PAP:
If it fails your assessment, it doesn’t go in your cart — or your portfolio.


Module 4 — Proceed: Buy with Intention

Objective: Execute trades only when your plan and assessment align.

At the Store:

  • Stick to the list and skip impulse buys.

  • Pay what you planned — not what’s on the end cap.

In the Market:

  • Enter positions only when setup matches your plan.

  • Follow position sizing rules (no overexposure).

  • Use stop-losses and trailing stops for accountability.

Key Phrase: “Plan. Assess. Proceed — never improvise.”


Module 5 — When You Shop Hungry (Without PAP)

Objective: Expose what emotional investing looks like in practice.

Hungry Shopper

Impulsive Investor

Buys junk food and regrets it later.

Buys meme stocks or hype tickers.

Feels satisfied short-term, but worse later.

Gets dopamine hit from “buy” clicks.

Overspends.

Overtrades.

Wastes food.

Wastes capital.

Result: Full cart, empty wallet.
Prevention: Run PAP before every trade or transaction.


Module 6 — Risk Control: Your Shopping Budget

Objective: Learn to manage financial “calories.”

At the Store:

  • You wouldn’t spend grocery money on electronics.

  • You wouldn’t buy food you can’t store.

In the Market:

  • Don’t invest what you can’t afford to lose.

  • Diversify (protein, produce, carbs = sectors, ETFs, bonds).

  • Keep cash reserved for true opportunities.

Budget Tip:
If you wouldn’t overspend at the store, don’t overleverage in the market.


Module 7 — Review the Cart Before Checkout

Objective: Audit before you commit.

At the Store:

  • Scan your basket. Remove duplicates or waste.

In the Market:

  • Check your portfolio for redundancy.

  • Trim overlapping positions.

  • Confirm allocation still matches your goals.

Best Practice:

  • Run a “quarterly cart review.”

  • Journal every trade: what triggered it and whether it aligned with your Plan–Assess–Proceed framework.


Module 8 — Long-Term Nutrition: Building a Healthy Portfolio

Objective: Focus on sustainability, not excitement.

At the Store:

  • Choose balanced meals.

  • Avoid junk and fad diets.

In the Market:

  • Build a core portfolio of diversified, compounding assets.

  • Avoid fads, “hot tips,” and one-hit-wonder trades.

  • Add variety — growth, income, safety, cash.

Healthy Portfolio = Balanced Diet

Type

Grocery Analogy

Investing Equivalent

Vegetables

Boring but essential

Index ETFs

Protein

Core strength

Blue-chip stocks

Treats

Small indulgence

Speculative trades

Water

Always needed

Cash reserves


Module 9 — The PAP Protocol in Practice

Objective: Apply PAP daily in both life and investing.

Step

Question to Ask

Example

Plan

What’s my goal and how much can I risk?

“I’ll invest $1,000 monthly into diversified ETFs.”

Assess

Does this align with my plan and risk limits?

“This stock fits my growth objective at fair value.”

Proceed

Am I following my plan — or chasing emotion?

“Entry confirmed. Stop-loss placed. Move on.”

Use PAP before every:

  • Trade

  • Portfolio rebalance

  • Strategy change

  • Emotional decision


Module 10 — The Final Analogy: Grocery List vs. Trading Plan

Objective: Reinforce the metaphor with practical symmetry.

Grocery Shopper

Smart Investor

Eats first → avoids hunger buys

Waits for setups → avoids FOMO

Makes a list → avoids waste

Builds a plan → avoids random trades

Checks labels → avoids poor quality

Assesses fundamentals → avoids weak stocks

Buys what’s needed → stays disciplined

Proceeds only with alignment → stays focused

Reviews receipt → learns spending patterns

Reviews trades → learns performance habits


Capstone: The PAP Mindset

The market, like the supermarket, is full of temptation.
Without PAP, you’ll leave with emotional decisions and empty results.

With PAP, every purchase — whether groceries or stocks — serves a purpose:

  • Plan what matters.

  • Assess with logic.

  • Proceed with discipline.

“An undisciplined investor fills their portfolio like a hungry shopper fills their cart — fast, messy, and full of regret.”

Master PAP. Build habits, not hype. Feed your wealth, not your impulses.

Did this answer your question?